Sniff Test: Does Your Client's Estate Plan Still Hold Up?

Spoiled milk doesn't announce itself. You don't get a warning. You just open the fridge one day, take a sniff, and realize that something that was perfectly fine the last time you checked has quietly stopped being what it was.

Estate plans work exactly the same way.

Earlier this year, Ryan L. Goldschmitt, WMCP, founder of Geminus Wealth Partners, began working with a couple who had recently married. One spouse had estate documents from years before the wedding, still valid, still legally in effect, still sitting in a drawer somewhere. But something was off: the healthcare proxy still named their mother. They had assumed marriage quietly updated all of that. It hadn't.

Ryan asked them the question he asks every client who comes in with existing documents: if something happened tomorrow, would you want those documents to play out exactly as written? Their answer was no. That weekend, they built their first estate plan together. A few months later, they refined it. Now a yearly review lives on their calendar.

"Ownership rarely arrives all at once," Ryan said. "It grows, one small choice at a time."

That couple's story captures something the Trust & Will Financial Advisor Contributor Panel hears constantly: clients who have a plan, but one that expired somewhere along the way, drafted for a different marriage, a different financial picture, or by someone whose priorities weren't theirs. I asked the panel how they help clients catch it before something goes wrong.

Most People Don't Know It's Gone Bad

The most common version of this problem is also the quietest: the plan is outdated, and nobody noticed.

Alan Gorlick, CEO of Gorlick Financial Strategies, has a consistent process for finding the expiration date. He starts by asking clients what they want to happen when they're gone. They always know. Then he asks to see the documents that reflect that. "When I look at it, it almost never matches," he said, "because it was written in a different environment or by someone who took it off the internet without even really understanding what they need."

A will drafted during a first marriage. A beneficiary form filled out at a first job. A trust built around a business that no longer exists. Each made sense at the time. None of them anticipated the life that followed. The plan didn't fail; it just quietly went past its date.

A Label That No Longer Reflects What's Inside

Charles Thomas III, CFP®, Founder of Intrepid Eagle Finance, sees a version of expiration that looks different from the outside: the plan that appears fresh but has gone stale where it counts.

A client comes in with a trust. The documents are polished, professionally drafted, filed away somewhere safe. Then Charles starts inventorying assets and finds almost nothing held inside it. The funding instructions were one paragraph at the back of the packet. Somewhere between the attorney's office and the rest of life, the follow-through never happened.

"These documents look really pretty, everything looks great," he said, "but you didn't actually make use of it." The trust exists. The protection doesn't. The label says one thing. The contents say another.

Charles now treats asset inventory as a standard part of every estate plan review. A document that was never properly funded isn't a safety net; it's a container that was never filled.

When The Expiration Affects Everything Else In The Fridge

Al Faber, CFP®, Founder of DIWY Financial Planning, thinks about expired plans from a perspective most advisors overlook: the people who inherit the consequences.

Estate planning is almost always built around the person leaving the estate. But the beneficiaries are the ones who end up navigating a plan they had no part in designing, working through provisions that made sense once and may not anymore, managing logistics that were never explained to them.

Al recently worked through a case where an attorney had set up a life estate allowing someone to remain in their home (a clean, well-intentioned arrangement at the time). But one of the named beneficiaries had since passed away, and the remaining family was now sorting through complications no one had anticipated. "One of the things I do with clients when I look at their estate plan," Al said, "is to say: tell me about your goals, what you're trying to accomplish, and then, have you discussed it with your beneficiaries so you're all on the same page?"

That conversation surfaces things the original documents never accounted for. It's far easier to have it now than to leave it for the people who come after.

Expired Doesn't Just Mean Outdated: It Can Mean Harmful

Chitra Patel, Founder and CEO of WealthWorth, is direct about what happens when a plan has been past its date for too long: it stops being neutral and starts doing damage.

She starts every inherited plan review the same way: set the documents aside, understand who the client is today, and then evaluate whether what's on paper still serves that person. Sometimes an update is all it takes. But sometimes the misalignment runs deeper: outdated beneficiaries, fiduciaries who are no longer the right fit, trust provisions that have become restrictive in ways the original grantor never intended.

"In those cases," she said, "keeping the old plan can be more harmful than having no plan at all."

The assumption most clients carry is that something is always better than nothing: that any document, however dated, offers some protection. For plans that have drifted far enough from a client's actual life, that assumption doesn't hold. A plan that routes assets to the wrong people, or grants authority to someone who shouldn't have it, creates problems rather than preventing them.

"Our job is to help clients take ownership of their estate plan and ensure it reflects who they are today," Chitra said, "not who they were ten years ago."

Time To Open The Fridge

Ryan's couple didn't overhaul everything at once. They started with the essentials, came back a few months later, and kept going from there. That's how it usually works: not a single dramatic revision, but a series of small decisions that gradually bring a plan back to current.

The advisors on this panel have all seen what happens when that process never starts, when a plan sits in a drawer through marriages, moves, and milestones until something forces the issue. An outdated healthcare proxy. An unfunded trust. A beneficiary designation that points somewhere it shouldn't.

You wouldn't drink the milk without checking the date. Your estate plan deserves the same habit.

Interested in partnering with Trust & Will to enhance your own clients' estate planning needs? Learn more about how you can join over 20,000 financial advisors and firms who are delivering peace of mind to their clients by offering a comprehensive estate planning solution. Sign up for free today.

Trust & Will is an online service providing legal forms and information. We are not a law firm and we do not provide legal advice.